%20(2).png)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
Choosing where to buy a home inthe Milwaukee area isn't just about finding the right house—it's aboutunderstanding where your investment dollars deliver the most value for yourlifestyle. Two communities that consistently top buyers' lists are Brookfieldand Hartland, but they offer very different value propositions.
If you're weighing these twoexcellent Lake Country options, this comprehensive comparison will help youunderstand exactly what you get for your money in each community.
Before diving into specifics,let's look at the current landscape. Brookfield typically commands a medianhome price of around $425,000, while Hartland comes in at approximately $365,000—that'sa 14% difference right off the bat. But the story goes deeper than just thepurchase price.
In terms of price per squarefoot, Brookfield averages $185 compared to Hartland's $155. That 16% differencemeans you're getting significantly more space for your money in Hartland. Andwhen it comes to land, the gap widens even further—Brookfield's average lotsize is 0.35 acres, while Hartland offers a generous 0.85 acres. That's 143%more land in Hartland.
The bottom line up front: InHartland, your dollar buys you more square footage, significantly more land,and lower overall costs. In Brookfield, you're paying a premium for proximityto Milwaukee, established amenities, and a more urban-suburban feel.
Let's get specific with areal-world price point that many Milwaukee-area buyers are working with.
At the $400,000 price point inBrookfield, you're typically looking at a home between 2,200 and 2,500square feet with 3-4 bedrooms and 2.5 bathrooms. Your lot willlikely be between 0.25 and 0.40 acres—enough for a nice yard, but notsprawling.
Most homes in this range areupdated ranches or two-story traditionals built between the 1980s and 2000s,though you'll find some newer construction. You'll get a 2-car attached garage,and many homes feature finished basements and updated kitchens. The big sellingpoint? You're close to everything—shopping, dining, and entertainment are allwithin minutes.
That same $400,000 in Hartlandstretches considerably further. You're looking at 2,800 to 3,200 square feet—that's400 to 600 more square feet than Brookfield. You'll typically find 4-5bedrooms and 3 to 3.5 bathrooms, giving growing families the space theyneed.
Lot sizes range from 0.75 to 1.5acres, often backing to woods or wetlands for added privacy. Homes tend to bespacious colonials or walkout ranches built in the 1990s through 2010s.Three-car garages are common, often with extra storage space. The walkoutbasements and premium lots with natural surroundings are major draws for buyersseeking a more rural feel.
The takeaway: For thesame investment, Hartland typically delivers 400-600 more square feet, anadditional bedroom, and 2-3 times the lot size.
One of the biggest factors inchoosing between these communities is your daily commute and how much you valuequick access to urban amenities.
If you're commuting to downtownMilwaukee, Brookfield offers a 20-25 minute drive compared to Hartland's35-40 minutes. That's about 15 minutes each way, which adds up to 30minutes daily or 2.5 hours per week. Over a year, Brookfield residents saveapproximately 130 hours of commute time.
For those working in theBrookfield Square area (a major employment hub), Brookfield residents enjoy a5-10 minute commute, while Hartland residents face 20-25 minutes. Highwayaccess is excellent in Brookfield with I-94 and US-45, while Hartland relies onWI-16 and US-18, which are good but slightly less convenient.
Both communities arecar-dependent with walkability scores of 45 (Brookfield) and 35 (Hartland). Andif you're a frequent flyer, Milwaukee's Mitchell International Airport is 25minutes from Brookfield versus 40 minutes from Hartland.
The verdict: Brookfieldwins for daily commuters and those who value quick access to urban amenities.Hartland works better for remote workers or those with flexible schedules.
Both communities are served byhighly-rated school districts, but they offer different educationalexperiences.
Elmbrook consistently ranks inthe top 10 school districts in Wisconsin. With a 96% graduation rate andan average ACT score of 25.2, academic performance is exceptional. The districtoffers 25+ AP courses and maintains a 14:1 student-teacher ratio acrossapproximately 7,000 students.
Parents appreciate thecomprehensive programming, extensive extracurricular offerings, and theresources that come with a larger, well-funded district. If you want thehighest test scores and the most course options, Elmbrook delivers.
Arrowhead ranks in the top 15in Wisconsin with a 95% graduation rate and a 24.8 average ACT score. Thedistrict offers 20+ AP courses with a 15:1 student-teacher ratio acrossapproximately 4,500 students.
The smaller size creates acloser-knit community feel where students are more likely to know theirteachers and administrators personally. Parents often cite the strong sense ofschool pride and community involvement as major benefits.
The verdict: Bothdistricts are excellent. Elmbrook offers a larger, more comprehensive programwith slightly higher test scores. Arrowhead provides a strong education with acloser-knit, smaller school community feel.
Your daily quality of life issignificantly impacted by what's available in your immediate area.
Brookfield is an amenity-richenvironment. You have Brookfield Square Mall and The Corridor for shopping,with options ranging from Target and Costco to upscale boutiques. Groceryshopping is convenient with 10+ options including Whole Foods, Trader Joe's,Sendik's, and all the major chains.
The restaurant scene is diversewith 100+ options spanning virtually every cuisine you can imagine.Entertainment options include multiple movie theaters, golf courses, andrecreation centers. There's even a moderate nightlife scene with bars andentertainment venues.
Hartland offers a more limitedbut intentionally curated selection. Major shopping requires a 15-minute driveto Brookfield. You'll find 4-5 grocery stores (Festival, Pick 'n Save) thatcover the basics well.
The restaurant scene featuresabout 30 family-oriented establishments—you won't find every cuisine, butwhat's there is generally high-quality and locally-owned. Entertainmentrevolves around outdoor recreation: lake access, hiking trails, and community events.Nightlife is minimal, requiring a drive to nearby areas.
The verdict: Brookfieldfor variety, convenience, and sophisticated dining. Hartland for a quieter,family-focused restaurant scene and outdoor recreation.
Smart buyers know that thepurchase price is just the beginning. Let's break down what a $400,000 homereally costs monthly in each community.
Your mortgage payment will beidentical—$2,395 per month at 7% APR for 30 years. But property taxesdiffer: Brookfield averages $760 monthly while Hartland comes in at $640,saving Hartland residents $120 per month.
Homeowners insurance isslightly cheaper in Hartland at $130 versus Brookfield's $150. However,utilities run higher in Hartland ($320) compared to Brookfield ($280) due tolarger homes and more square footage to heat and cool.
Lawn and snow maintenance costsmore in Hartland ($180 monthly) compared to Brookfield ($100) because of thoselarger lots. Brookfield typically has HOA fees around $50 monthly, while manyHartland properties have no HOA.
The commute difference adds upat the gas pump. Brookfield residents average $200 monthly in commute costsversus $300 for Hartland residents—that extra 100 miles per week adds $100 toyour monthly transportation budget.
The surprising finding: Despitethe lower purchase price in Hartland, monthly costs are nearly identical at $3,935for Brookfield versus $3,965 for Hartland. The real savings in Hartlandcome from building equity in more square footage and land, not from monthlycost savings.
If you're thinking long-term,both communities have excellent track records, but with differentcharacteristics.
Over the past 10 years,Brookfield has seen 68% appreciation while Hartland has experienced 72%growth—remarkably similar performance. The 5-year numbers show Brookfieldat 42% and Hartland at 45%, with Hartland maintaining a slight edge.
Brookfield offers very highmarket stability and has historically been more insulated from economicdownturns. Homes sell faster too, with an average of 28 days on market comparedto Hartland's 35 days. This liquidity matters if you need to sell quickly.
Hartland's market is quitestable but slightly more susceptible to broader economic trends. However,renovations and upgrades tend to command a higher premium in Hartland—buyersare willing to pay more for well-executed improvements in this market.
The investment insight: Bothmarkets have performed exceptionally well. Brookfield offers more stability andfaster resale, while Hartland has shown slightly stronger growth and offersmore room to add value through improvements.
Brookfield makes the most sensefor buyers who prioritize convenience and established suburban living.
• You work in downtown Milwaukee or need frequenturban access. You'll save 200+ hours per year in commute time compared toHartland—that's five full work weeks you get back annually.
• You value walkable amenities and convenience. Everythingyou need is within 10 minutes, from Costco to specialty boutiques, makingerrands and daily life incredibly efficient.
• You prefer a more established, suburban feel. Matureneighborhoods with sidewalks, streetlights, and consistent home values create atraditional suburban atmosphere.
• You're empty nesters downsizing. Brookfieldoffers plenty of maintenance-free condos and smaller homes in establishedneighborhoods, perfect for those looking to simplify.
• You want the strongest school district rankings. Elmbrookconsistently ranks in Wisconsin's top 5, making it a draw for familiesprioritizing education.
• You don't need a lot of land. Quarter-acre lotsare the norm, which means less time on maintenance and more time for otheractivities.
Hartland appeals to buyers whowant more space, privacy, and connection to nature.
• You want significantly more space for your money. You'llget 30-40% more house and 200-300% more land at similar price points—that'stransformative for growing families.
• You work remotely or have a flexible schedule. Theextra commute becomes irrelevant if you're not driving daily, and you'llappreciate the home office space.
• You value privacy and natural surroundings. Largerlots often back to woods, wetlands, or have substantial buffers from neighbors,creating a secluded feel while still being part of a community.
• You have a growing family. More bedrooms, morebathrooms, and yards large enough for playscapes, sports equipment, and activekids make Hartland ideal for families.
• You enjoy outdoor recreation. Direct access toKettle Moraine trails, lake activities, and nature means weekend adventuresstart at your back door.
• You want room for hobbies or storage. Three-cargarages, workshop space, and basements sized for rec rooms give you flexibilityfor whatever interests you pursue.
There's no wrong choice betweenBrookfield and Hartland—only the wrong choice for you.
Choose Brookfield if: Convenience,commute time, and established suburban living outweigh the desire for space.You're willing to pay a premium for proximity and amenities, and you valueefficiency in your daily life.
Choose Hartland if: Space,land, and a more rural feel matter more than being close to everything. Youvalue privacy and want more home for your investment, and you're willing todrive a bit further for urban amenities.
While this comparison focusedon Brookfield vs. Hartland, don't overlook these alternatives:
Want the best of both worlds?Look at Pewaukee—positioned geographically between Brookfield andHartland with pricing that splits the difference. You get lake access andreasonable commutes.
Need more luxury? ExploreDelafield for upscale lake living and resort-style amenities. It's thepremium option in Lake Country.
Prioritizing walkability? ConsiderWauwatosa for true urban-suburban living with Milwaukee accessibility.You can walk to restaurants, shops, and parks.
Budget-conscious? Lookat Sussex or Merton for similar Hartland value with even lower prices.You'll sacrifice some amenities but gain even more affordability.
The numbers tell part of thestory, but nothing replaces experiencing these communities in person. Ispecialize in helping buyers navigate the Lake Country and Brookfield markets,and I can show you exactly what your budget buys in each area.
Whether you're drawn toBrookfield's convenience or Hartland's spaciousness, I'll help you find a homethat matches both your lifestyle and your financial goals. We'll tourproperties, explore neighborhoods during different times of day, and I'll shareinsights about each community that you won't find online.
Ready to compare homes inperson? Contact me today for a personalized tour of Brookfield and Hartlandproperties in your price range. Let's turn this comparison into your nextaddress.
If you prioritize shortestcommute to Milwaukee, choose Brookfield.
If you want the most squarefeet per dollar, choose Hartland.
If you need the largest lotsizes, choose Hartland.
If you want the highestschool rankings, choose Brookfield.
If shopping and diningvariety matters, choose Brookfield.
If outdoor recreation accessis key, choose Hartland.
If you need the fastest homeresale, choose Brookfield.
If privacy and naturalsetting are priorities, choose Hartland.
If walkability to amenitiesmatters, choose Brookfield.
If you're looking for lowestmonthly costs, it's a tie between both.
Have questions about specific neighborhoods withinBrookfield or Hartland? Want to see current listings that match your criteria?Contact Stacie Krajcir for expert guidance on finding your perfect Lake Countryhome.
Have a question for Stacie Krajcir? You can set up a time to talk or reach out by email at the address below.
.png)
.png)
.png){kind=icon}
%20(1).png)
%20(1).png)
.png)
%20(1).png)
.png){kind=icon}